HomeLegalVeteransHow-Do-I-Appeal-A-Va-Benefits-Decision

A Comprehensive Guide to Navigating Your VA Benefits Appeal

Guide to Successfully Appealing a VA Benefits Decision

When you receive a decision about your claim for benefits from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), the outcome may not always align with your expectations. Whether your claim is denied or you receive a lower rating than you feel you deserve, know that you have options to contest. The appeals process may seem complex, but understanding how it works and following the right steps can help ensure your appeal is successful. This comprehensive guide will offer insights into the process and steps for appealing a VA benefits decision.

Understanding the VA Benefits Decision

The first step towards launching a successful appeal against a VA benefits decision is understanding the workings of the VA benefits decisions. Once the VA legalizes a decision on your claim, you'll receive a letter in the mail. The communique carries an explanation behind the decision, including a list of the evidence considered, the laws and regulations used to decide, and instructions on how to appeal if you're dissatisfied.

The VA Appeals Process

The VA has a specific appeal process known as Appeals Modernization Act’ which removes the traditional process of appealing. The new process, which was effective from February 19, 2019, provides Veterans with three review options, including:

  • Supplemental Claim
  • Higher-Level Review
  • Appeal to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals

Understanding these three options is crucial in making a successful appeal.

Supplemental Claim

If you have additional evidence that was not included in your original claim, you can opt for a supplemental claim. This new evidence must be ‘new and relevant’ and you should submit it within one year from the date on your decision notice. During this process, a VA reviewer examines the new evidence and makes a decision.

Higher-Level Review

If you have no new evidence but believe that there was an error in the initial decision, you can request a higher-level review. During this process, a senior VA reviewer will look at your claim and all the evidence provided in the initial claim. They can overturn the initial decision based on a difference of opinion or if they find an obvious error.

Appeal to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals

You can also appeal to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals, commonly known as BVA or the Board. Here, you can have your appeal reviewed in three ways:

  • Direct review: Here, a Veterans Law Judge would take a look at the same evidence considered by the original claims processor. No new evidence is allowed in this review.
  • Evidence Submission: You can submit additional evidence within 90 days of your notice of disagreement. This new evidence will then be supplied to the Veterans Law Judge for consideration.
  • Hearing: In this mode, you get to have a hearing with Veterans Law Judge where you can present new evidence or testify in person or via videoconference. After the hearing, you get to submit additional evidence within 90 days.

Deciding on an Appeal Option

The slogan ‘one denial doesn't mean you will never receive VA benefits’ should give you the morale you need to soldier on. Remember, it is crucial that you decide which appeal option is best for your situation. You could consult with a VA-accredited attorney, claims agent, or Veterans Service Officer. Take your time and weigh your options before deciding the best route to take.

Filing Your Appeal

Once you've weighed your options and chosen the best way forward, it's time to file your appeal. Depending upon which process you choose, there are different methods to file your appeal:

For Supplemental Claims and Higher-Level Reviews

You can file online at VA.gov, fill out VA Form 20-0995 (for a Supplemental Claim) or 20-0996 (for a Higher-Level Review) and submit it by mail, or go in person at a VA regional office.

For Appeals to Board of Veterans’ Appeals

You can file online at VA.gov, fill out VA Form 10182 and submit it by mail, or go in person at a VA regional office.

Waiting for your Appeals Decision

Once your appeal is filed, patience is the next step. The timeline for receiving a decision on an appeal varies based on the type and complexity of your appeal. You can check the status of your appeal online by visiting the VA's website

Receiving Your Decision

Once your appeal has been reviewed, the VA will send you a decision packet in the mail. This packet will contain detailed information about the VA's decision. If the appeal is successful, the letter will detail the benefits you are entitled to. However, if your appeal is denied, the letter will contain the reasons for the denial and options moving forward.

Further Appeal Options

If you weren’t happy with the VA’s decision in the appeals process, you still have further options. You could appeal to the U.S Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC), the U.S Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, or even to the Supreme Court of the United States.

Key Takeaways

Remember, successfully appealing a VA benefits decision is all about preparation, patience, and persistence. Having additional evidence, being wise in decision-making, being ready to consult where necessary, and willingness to explore all options available, will strengthen your appeal journey. Keep the courage and give yourself the best chance to obtain the benefits you have earned and deserve.